Connecticut Custom Airguns
  • Welcome!
  • Hector's Airgun Blog
  • Products and Products Blog
    • One-Off's
    • The "Héctors Special'" scope by Sightron
    • K1050i FT
    • The Hex Louver or "Secret Sunshade"
    • Pellet Path Calculator >
      • Questions, Answers and Comments on P-P Calc
      • Privacy Policy for PP-Calc
    • The Nautilus SideWheel
    • The X-10 TiltMeter
  • Zimmer-Silhouetten
    • Results 2017-2018
    • Results 2016-2017
    • Results 2015-2016
    • Results 2014-2015
    • Results 2013-2014
  • References and Links
  • Contact us
  • Store

Hector's Airgun Blog

Where we discuss, CIVIILY,  anything airgun.

Return Home

Let's talk springs

8/4/2019

1 Comment

 

Opening comments

For some time now, I've been wanting to post this entry, but had been unable to find the time.
Courtesy of our friends at Aer Lingus, that delayed my departure from Washington (Dulles) and made me loose my connection to Birmingham (and the World's FT Matches), I've had to sit in the airport then attempt a boarding, only to be denied boarding on account of my "firearm".
You see, there are planes in the Aer Lingus fleet where you can access the hold, so in those planes, "firearms" cannot travel.
It doesn't matter that it is a single shot, pellet rifle, disassembled, and unloaded (obviously, who in their right mind would carry a cocked springer without a stock and with an exposed trigger?!)
The computer terminal says it cannot travel and the employees cannot exercise neither judgement, nor criterion, they are not allowed to think.
Picture
So, what better usage of the time than to do what I had not been able to do?
So, let's talk springs!
This entry will be completely different from all the others in the sense that it will try to PROPOSE improvements to the current state of the art, more than analyzing what is the current state of the art.
I believe that more informed consumers will always drive manufacturers to a better product and in the end, we all win.

Suggestions for improvement open to all Manufacturers

We'll limit ourselves to the metal (steel) coiled spring for this entry. If there is enough interest, we can talk a little about gas springs, but the metal spring is complex enough to warrant a complete entry on its own.
Let's start with some clarification of concepts:

A steel spring is a series of coils. You might say that is obvious, but the truth is that what is not obvious is that each coil behaves more or less independently and in those things where they act together are those factors that affect the interlinkage of the coils and have the most effect in the long term life of the spring.

Like a train, if a spring is not properly "loaded" it will get de-railed.
Experienced railroaders know that if you put the light cars in the middle, and the heavy ones in front and in back the train "stretches" and cannot follow the tracks (like "Tootle").
So, trains are "loaded" in certain order and then locomotives are inserted at strategic points in very long trains (in excess of 100 cars).
It is not uncommon in the US to see long haul cargo trains with up to 16 locomotives distributed along the beginning, the end, and both(1st and 2nd) thirds of over 170 cars.

An airgun mainspring is not that different.
Its relation of Overall length (OAL) to Outside Diameter (OD) renders them very "slender", and so, prone to "derailment" (kinking), stretching and knocking (twang), and even bumping (buzzing or vibrating).

So, how could we build a better spring?

​SOME improvements could come from the science of materials.

In the automotive industry the effect of different alloys, heat treatment, methods of heat treatment, surface finishes and even coatings has been studied in depth.

Those of you that are old enough will remember that valve springs would hardly last 10-15,000 miles without loosing some of its "oomph", this required constant "tuning" of the engine. Usually, every 3-5,000 miles, and then change of springs.
Modern valve springs will last well over 100,000 miles.  Even "racing" springs can now last at least a season (not an interesting aspect in high budget racing, like F1, but interesting in other forms).
Up until 50 years ago, High Carbon steel spring as produced by the US or Swedish firms was the top material. A concerted effort on the part of Japanese car makers brought a full range of innovations: Chromium was added, then Silicon, then heat treatment prior to winding, then Vanadium was added to the wire (not as an alloy), lastly Cobalt; and very serious studies have been conducted about what is what TRULY defines the fatigue and temperature resistance of springs, to this date, most (by volume) truly high quality spring steel is produced in Japan.

Of course, given the vertical integration of the Japanese economy where the same "group" is composed of companies ranging from mining conglomerates to car making (Mitsubishi is a good example), or where the close alliances between industry, banking and commerce create de-facto groups (Sumitomo), it is not complicated to setup an institute to research these things.

Luckily, they are generally open with those things that are at least 5-7 years old, and we can take a peek into what it is the current, published, state of the art.

So, let's compare how successive generations of valve spring steel compare to "piano wire" or "conventional steel":

Do note that this table is courtesy of Sumitomo Electric, so the names  of the steel are "commercial":
Picture
This is how the Japanese standards call and classify the steels used:
Picture
Do note that, by now, the Carbon (C), Manganese (Mn), Nickel (Ni), Chromium (Cr), and Vanadium (V), have reached pretty uniform compositions, and the difference between one "normal" grade (SOTHN) and the "super" grade (SWOHS) is a small further addition of Silicon (Si) 

And this is where Sumitomo is currently, adding Cobalt (Co):
Picture
Now, if you are wondering why the complication in adding more and more materials to the alloy, and also to the metal itself, it is mainly because the current, complete process of spring fabrication is a lot more complicated than just "winding":
Picture
Those of you that have some experience with materials and heat treatment will wonder why the quenching shows a higher temperature than the drawing or the tempering, and this is something that is peculiar to these very complex steels:

Pulling the wire through dies creates some work hardening as it is "drawn", but then this hardening needs to be quenched in molten baths (either lead or salt composites) at a higher temperature than that of the drawing.
Steel at this point would have little hardness and little tenacity/toughness, so it needs tempering.
After tempering, then the spring is wound or coiled.
But this tempering process, even if it is conducted at relatively low temperature, requires some annealing in order to make the spring less fragile.
Then the surface is treated with Nitrides in order to create a "case" that exhibits superior resistance to the starting of cracks and fissures which are the weak spots where the spring breaks, while still retaining a "core" with tenacity and toughness.
But while niitriding creates the chemical aspects conducive  to surface hardness, it also stresses the surface itself. So these stresses need to be relieved and the most economical way to relieve them is to "shot-peen" the spring (some manufacturers use small bits of wire to shot peen, not actual spherical shot).
Finally, the spring is subject to a certain portion of maximum allowable stress and "aged" by the strain this stress creates (what we would call "setting", though we set the springs by compressing the FIRST time to fully solid condition).

There are techniques to strain-age airgun springs, but not all airguns are suitable for them.

After all these processes, the resultant spring is capable of MILLIONS of operations within the design parameters, and here we note that NO AUTOMOTIVE spring reaches the compression ratio of airgun mainsprings.

Would an airgun spring manufacturer be able to buy these super-special steels?

Maybe, I really do not know. My calls for information went somewhat unheeded as to what material each manufacturer uses, so I cannot tell you who uses what and what processes are applied to our airgun springs.
I am sure that they all do the best they can within the constraints of the costs they can face. And this is an important consideration.
An OEM spring costs between $0.50 and $4, an aftermarket spring costs about $10, some VERY special aftermarket springs can cost up to $25, most of them are sold for between 2 and 3 times the cost, not all of them are truly worth the price the consumer pays but, when you consider that a gas spring, in industrial assembly quantities can cost between $5 and $25, it is clear that extremely advanced steel springs will never make it to the OEM piston gun.

Now let's look at a little geometry

We said in the beginning that a spring is a series of coils that act more or less independently from each other, and that is a good way to start to understand springs.
The first coil supports and pushes the second that in turn does the same with the third, etc. BUT if we think about this closely, we will understand that the first coil is pushing ALL the next coils, and that in the other extreme, the last coil is pushing the piston itself. 
Yes it receives the support and push from all the previous coils, but this difference make the "distribution of labor" different for each coil depending on WHERE that coil is in the spring.
This concept also clarifies that the WEIGHT each coil is pushing, depends on the position in the spring.
And lastly, this concept also helps us understand that once the whole length of the compression chamber has been run by the piston, and the piston itself suffers the pushback from the pellet's inertia/resistance and high pressure thereby developed, a whole mayhem of disorderly conduct ensues. Some coils go back while others go forward, and some stay more or less stationary. These "travelling waves" of steel actually make the spring perform several compressions and decompressions for every shot cycle.

The most common way to solve that is to use a tight fitting guide.
A tight fitting guide will provide some coils with enough friction to dampen their movement.
And so, we eliminate the twang and the buzz.
We also reduce the double and triple duty cycle that some coils perform.
But, as much as we would like to reduce completely this aspect, we cannot. We cannot introduce so much friction that the extra movement of the coils is completely arrested. We would not get the speed we need to drive the pellet.
So, we need to accept that as long as we use a coiled steel spring, we will need a tight guide, or accept the twang and the buzz.

The natural question here is: Why don't manufacturers use a tight guide from the start?
Answer lies in the cost, of course.
And the REAL answer is that to make the springs, the steel needs to be coiled (remember the 4th step in the manufacturing process?). 
How do we do that?
Some of you may answer that you take a mandrel, and coil the spring around the mandrel. 
Well, that was true in the old days.
Fairly elaborate mandrels were turned to set the "pitch" of the spring, and the diameters had to be not only calculated, but then rectified by actually making a number of springs.
Because, depending on the force you use to restrain the wire from winding freely, the spring will always be fatter than the mandrel; more force, less difference between mandrel's outside diameter and spring's inside diameter.

Nowadays, springs are wound using mandrel-less machines that simply start bending the wire along an adjustable curve and the spring wire is "pushed" into form, not stretched.

This means that you are not limited by the length of your mandrel. You can make REALLY long springs. And you can also adjust the dimensions to a fine degree: Inside Diameter (ID), Outside Diameter (OD), Pitch (P).
​
Some aspects that are seldom questioned are:  What is the INTERNAL geometry of the spring, and why, where and how does the spring accumulated energy?

To understand that we need to look into what is the "Neutral Fiber", "Neutral plane", or "Neutral Axis"
Picture
1 Comment
Kirk Schwarz
2/8/2020 20:43:41

Cool stuff Hector - were lucky to have you!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Hector Medina

    2012 US National WFTF Spring Piston Champion
    2012 WFTF Spring Piston Grand Prix Winner
    2013 World's WFTF Spring Piston 7th place
    2014 Texas State WFTF Piston Champion
    2014 World's WFTF Spring Piston 5th place.
    2015 Maine State Champion WFTF Piston
    2015 Massachusetts State Champion WFTF Piston
    2015 New York State Champion WFTF Piston
    2015 US National WFTF Piston 2nd Place
    2016 Canadian WFTF Piston Champion
    2016 Pyramyd Air Cup WFTF Piston 1st Place
    2017 US Nationals Open Piston 3rd Place
    2018 WFTC's Member of Team USA Champion Springers
    2018 WFTC's 4th place Veteran Springer
    2020 Puerto Rico GP Piston First Place
    2020 NC State Championships 1st Place Piston
    2022 Maryland State Champion WFTF 

    Archives

    April 2022
    February 2022
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

    Categories

    All
    Events
    Gear
    Hunting
    Tests

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly