Connecticut Custom Airguns
  • Welcome!
  • Hector's Airgun Blog
  • Products and Products Blog
    • One-Off's
    • The "Héctors Special'" scope by Sightron
    • K1050i FT
    • The Hex Louver or "Secret Sunshade"
    • Pellet Path Calculator >
      • Questions, Answers and Comments on P-P Calc
      • Privacy Policy for PP-Calc
    • The Nautilus SideWheel
    • The X-10 TiltMeter
  • Zimmer-Silhouetten
    • Results 2017-2018
    • Results 2016-2017
    • Results 2015-2016
    • Results 2014-2015
    • Results 2013-2014
  • References and Links
  • Contact us
  • Store

Hector's Airgun Blog

Where we discuss, CIVIILY,  anything airgun.

Return Home

The "SuperCustom" triggers for the Walther LGU and LGV.

5/24/2018

11 Comments

 

A short review of the Rowan Engineering's trigger blade, with some comments about the BMS trigger

DISCLAIMER, I will post the same disclaimer as I used in the original post about swapping triggers in the LGU:

1.- Swapping the trigger blades WILL invalidate the warranty of your rifle.
2.- ANY user intervention in the trigger MAY result in an UNSAFE condition. Once you get into the trigger you are on your own.
3.- I have no control of YOUR actions, so I can take NO responsibility for the results YOU get. This process proved safe and sound in THIS gun. I cannot guarantee that it will be the same in YOURS.

Having said that, let's dive into it:


In the past years, I have had the opportunity to tune and shoot a number of LGV's and LGU's, and I still like the guns. They are not the ideal gun for me (though the LGV seems to be a better match), but as we have discussed in the past, we are all different and some guns will shoot very well in some people's hands while shooting horribly in someone else's hands.

Among the most important characteristic of a gun that is to shoot accurately many times in a day, is the trigger. For most shooters, the Walther "Match Abzug", or the "Yankee Tune" trigger solutions will be all they ever need, or want.
I have installed a few of the "super-custom" triggers (like the BMS's and the RE's), but there was always something that didn't really "jive" for me; perhaps I am spoiled by my DIANA T-06's. But, as we just said: we are all different. And so, when a friend asked me to add a Rowan Engineering trigger to his LGU and document the process, I decided to put this blog entry together.
Experiences with Rowan have been somewhat less than stellar.
As an example:
When I ordered this last trigger through the website, everything seemed to be straightforward, when I received an Email from them supposedly enclosing the tracking number, but without any number at all, I suspected that there would be other problems.
So, after writing to them and receiving the proper tracking number, I followed the shipment almost daily.
When suddenly the USPS sent me an alert (I have a USPS account and had registered to receive updates on the package), about the "item being returned to sender because it is undeliverable", I jumped into action and went looking for the package to my local Zip-Code head office, sure enough, after 90 minutes of waiting and repeating the same story several times, someone took pity on me (actually the Germantown, MD, USA, PostMaster), and personally went to look for the parcel.

When I received it, I understood the whole ("Undeliverable")  thing:​
Picture
Tell me in all honesty ¿Would you have been able to deliver such a package? I wouldn't.
An Email to them relaying the same picture included above produced the following response:

"Hello Hector,
 
I have found out what happened with the address.
 
Occasionally the printed address is missing some detail that is hand written afterwards.
To stop this smudging , clear tape is added over which we have been doing for several years.
 
It appears now that the last batch of print consumables is different or the the clear tape has changed in someway and now over a day or so causes the printed ink underneath to erase !!!
Very strange.
 
Anyhow, we will not add the clear tape from now onwards.
 
Best regards,
Derek Rose."


By the end of the day, I only lost 3 hours hunting down the package but now I had it in hand.
​
Anyway, back to gunsmithing:
This is what you get in the envelope:
Picture
And when you unpack it, this is what is inside:
Picture
You will also get a black and white printed version of the instruction booklet:
http://rowanengineering.com/pdf/WalterLGVLGUAdjTriggerInstruct.pdf
One of the things that strikes any observant gunsmith is that the adjustment screws (as the trigger is shipped) are even further apart than the ones in Walther's "Match Abzug"
Picture
If we do the same comparison with the BMS trigger:
Picture
So, how can it accomplish a lower trigger pull with screws that are even farther apart than the OEM triggers?
Reality is, that as it is shipped, it can't FOR THE SAME SET OF CIRCUMSTANCES.
You can read carefully, again, and again, and AGAIN, the instruction sheet included, there is no mention of further adjustability.
Picture
But if you look closely, you can see that there is a third hole in there. And it is tapped for the same screws. So, if what you REALLY want is the lightest trigger pull possible without any further work, then you need to change the rear screw's location from the outside to the center.
But, in a sense, we are getting ahead of ourselves because when I installed the RE's trigger in THIS Walther, then the piston would not make the trigger latch onto the stem.
I looked and looked and looked and could not find what the problem was, until I looked closely at the safety. It would not move to the safe position.

Upon close examination, it was determined that there was not enough space between the housing, the safety pawl and the new trigger blade for the pawl to enter into the cavity of the trigger.

My first reaction was to shim it a little, believing that the problem MUST be a minor one, a question of one or two thousandths of an inch.

I measured the thin washers in the trigger mechanism and made some of copper shim material of the same thickness:
Picture
Yes, I know they are not as elegant, but they fit and didn't snag on anything, so I tried one on the offending side. 
NO luck.
Tried two
NO luck
Tried three
Finally, the pawl could enter the trigger's cavity.
BUT, when I assembled the trigger, it was clearly wrong. Once assembled the housing put enough pressure onto the washers as to lock the parts (sear and blade).
So, what was there to do?

I remembered then that when discussing the trigger with the designer, we had talked about Zinc parts.
Few people really understand why, but those that have worked in precision moulding know that moulds that are made to mould zinc have a relatively short life. It's not that they get clogged, or they break, or they loose their definition, it's that they GROW on the inside. So, parts that are moulded become increasingly thick. A friend once told me that molten zinc dissolved iron/steel; and that is possible, as crucibles for melting zinc are usually ceramic, but I do not know this to be absolutely true, though I think it makes sense.

Not a problem when you know the tolerances and you can plan ahead and leave room for parts that may have up to 0.015" of extra room here and there, but when you design an aftermarket part you run the risk of not being able to use that part if the manufacturer has a little more tolerance built into its designs.
And so, the solution was to thin out the pawl a little, but it is a small part.

Well, part of the reason why early gunsmiths were also clock makers (Girandoni to name just one), was because we develop the tools and the eye to work to very small dimensions by hand.
​
​The small vice was taken out of storage and put to good use:
Picture
Once the offending 0.027" were taken off using needle files, the pawl entered smoothly into the trigger blade cavity when the piston's flat part of the latching button hit the safety extension lever:
Picture
Now, I assume that some of you are asking "why didn't you create some relief in the trigger blade itself?"
Well, the reason  is that RE has a very specific position where the trigger can be at the same time light AND safe. And IMHO there is NOTHING as dangerous as a gun that HAS an INOPERATIVE safety lever; it will lead people to believe it is a safe gun when in reality it is not. So, it was paramount to safeguard the functioning of the safety lever.

You may or may not have the need to do this to your gun, this one in particular was from the latest batch; hopefully, this issue will be corrected and hopefully by now you are ready to start the process of getting the trigger in line with what you want/need.


The booklet tells you to start where the old trigger was adjusted to, but where do you start when you had the OEM 1 screw trigger blade?

Well the answer is in this photo  (that you can find here):
Picture
​What is important here is the DIFFERENCE between the two screws HEIGHTS. Since the "watertables" of both trigger blades are not the same, we cannot ensure that the heights should be the same, but we CAN say that the difference in screw heights should be the same so, we took the height of the front trigger screw and added 0.95 mm's to the second height, and we used that as our starting point.
And, sure enough, the trigger pull changed little.
I then adjusted to the lowest possible weight and measured an average of 5 shots.
It was interesting to note that compared to the "Yankee Tune​", the difference was almost non measureable.
To take the experiment further, I moved the screw to the closer position (more forward), and re-tuned the trigger to the lowest possible weight that I still felt was "safe". It was then that we could observe some appreciable differences.
Picture
Here we need to add that adjusting the RE's trigger is not as easy as it should be, every time the screws need to be adjusted, the blade itself needs to be moved/removed. 
By the end of the day, the RE trigger was set to 17 oz. (close enough to 1# even) and the job was considered finished.

One important aspect is that if you need to work on your gun, remember to remove the trigger blade, as the trigger guard will not release the trigger with the blade on. 
You can modify your trigger guard to create room, but in general I do not advocate modifying structural parts and the trigger guard is an important part in the bedding of the LGU and LGV. They are not as "tunable" as DIANA mod. 34's using the rear stock to action screws, but a properly set and consistent trigger guard torque is important to achieve utmost accuracy in any gun.

Since I already had the trigger pull scale out and I had the rifle vise pointed at the pellet trap and everything was set, I decided to measure the trigger pull in my personal LGV (shooting at 16 ft-lbs in 0.177"), the average of 5 trigger pulls was 15.6 oz.
Sure enough, my LGV has stoned trigger parts and uses the "Walther Match Abzug".
Further, the trigger on the LGV feels "crisper" because once the force of the opposing sear spring has been overcome, the trigger pull is finished in a VERY SHORT DISTANCE. Whereas the BMS and the RE triggers need a longer distance to actually release the shot.
Nothing new or out of the ordinary here, it's a simple result of levers and fulcrum points. Longer lever, more force, but shorter distance. Shorter lever, less force needed, but a longer travel is required.

In here I would like to insert RE's response to the question of when the third screw hole had been added:

Hello Hector,
 
The additional tapped hole was added in the last few months, we’ve been producing the trigger for several years.
We often make incremental changes to our products and this was a result of one or two comments I have read on various forums that people have done themselves.
Like almost all manufactures, we don’t offer “upgrades” to the latest version during the product life cycle.
I’m not entirely convinced that the extra hole it is necessary or even gives an overall improvement, but was added so that customers who wished could experiment.
I find that although the new grub screw position will reduce the pull weight, it also increases the trigger creep which is very undesirable.
 
Our recommendation is to position the grub screws in the original intended position.
 
Best regards,
Derek Rose.


Couldn't have said it better myself! LOL!
Picture
​Which trigger is the best?  All of them, or none, it all depends. Remember we are all different, and depending on your habits and customs as related to shooting, one trigger may be better for you than the others.
An undisputable advantage of these "supercustom" triggers is that you can move the blade itself back and forth, and twist it a little, if that works better for you, the Match Abzug, or the OEM triggers do not have this facility.
A good gunsmith can set the release point to a reasonably wide latitude of positions forward and back, but moving the trigger blade itself makes more sense for the home tinkerer.

The BMS trigger does have more adjustability in the LENGTH of the first stage because the safety pawl to trigger relation is less demanding than in the RE's trigger.

That is part of the beauty of gunsmithing, there is so much variety!

Anyway, hope this short note helps you identify which trigger is better for you and why, and also may or may not save you some money because at around US$80 for the RE and US$140 for the BMS, getting some polishing stones and a longer M3 screw; or asking a friend to do it may make more sense.

Keep well and shoot straight!
11 Comments
LARRY PIRRONE link
5/29/2018 22:17:59

since I can no longer get into "air gun warriors no matter who I contact for how many times I attempt to re-register I have to comment here. Older versions of the RE trigger does not have the additional hole.

Larry

Reply
Hector Medina
5/30/2018 10:22:46

Hello Larry!

I am sorry to hear that AGW is not as responsive as it should be to a shooter like yourself. If someone has been a positive contributor to the fora all these years, it's you.

Anyway, I have contacted RE to see if there is any recourse for those triggers that do not have the middle position.

Of course you know that I can drill and tap the hole if you really want it, but IMHO, I prefer the crispness of Walther's Match Abzug to the mushy feeling/almost creep of the very light RE.

Thanks for reading!


HM

Reply
Mark
6/8/2018 19:53:30

I don't own a Walther LGU and probably never will but I still found your article to be useful- it's a good reminder of what's important about a trigger and what's less so.

Thanks!

Reply
Hector Medina
6/11/2018 11:52:44

Hello Mark!

Thanks for reading!
Never say never, Mark! LOL!

The truth is that LGV's (more than LGU's) can be practical, not too expensive and wonderful machines to shoot. The pleasure of shooting a truly accurate break barrel is hard to top! LOL!

Again, thanks for reading, take care!


HM

Reply
Doug Scott
4/5/2020 12:46:47

Hello Hector. I completed the yankee tune on my lgu and oddly have lost my 2nd stage. Any adjustment of the first stage length screw or 2nd Weight adjustments don’t give me a second stage point I can feel. The process seems simple enough. Not sure what to do. Was thinking the second stage break was as light as first stage so I increased second stage weight all the way in where the gun wouldn’t cock and backed out from there. No change. I am sure you’re time is valuable but if you could give me a thought on this I would appreciate it. Also can’t seem to get into AGW. Thanks so much. Doug

Reply
Hector Medina
4/6/2020 15:04:32

Hello Doug;

Sorry for the late reply, but weekends are weekends, even in these "peculiar" times.

GENERALLY, if you back out the FRONT screw a little, you will get a creepy second stage that is very noticeable. But, since I do not know where you are starting from, look at the picture of the protrusions of the screws in this post. That should give you a good STARTING point.
If you read our comment, it says that what is important is the DIFFERENCE in protrusions. As long as that difference is 0.95 mm's you should be on solid footing.

Try it and keep us posted!





HM

Reply
Doug Scott
4/6/2020 16:57:30

Thanks much for your thoughts. I was unsure to ask my question because the process is so simple, two screws to adjust, find the happy place. The 1st stage screws works well and can shorten it out to what must be 2nd stage only. My problem is in the lack of feeling an obvious stop between 1st and 2nd needed for good accuracy, I have noticed that reducing 1st stage to almost gone I can feel a 2nd stage but by then and with a light weight on the 2nd stage, the trigger fires, no real warning time. I’ll keep playing with it because it is crisper than the OEM. I didn’t want to open it up but have heard Tony Leech has a very good aluminum two screw replacement trigger. Might try that even though the safety will not work with it. Thanks again for responding and your time. Appreciate it.

Hector Medina
4/6/2020 17:03:13

Doug;

Then you need to screw in the second (rear) screw. To create a "stronger" second stage.It may be creepy, but it will be stronger.
I am working with an American Maker to get a really good trigger (adjustable button for finger contact) made for these fantastic airguns (and it will also be compatible with the Century, which is another airgun with lots of potential. So, give us a week to polish some aspects and you will see the second entry of this title in the blog.
Stay tuned . . .






HM

Reply
Doug Scott
4/6/2020 17:37:34

A stronger 2nd stage is exactly what I was thinking to. Good to have it confirmed. The weight adjustment is very fine if much change at all so it really takes focus. Love the LGU. Finest I have ever shot and is so much fun, really relieves stress going through the process of loading, shot focus and great accuracy. I’ll look for your new trigger post. Sounds interesting. So many love this gun but all seem to tinker with the trigger. Thanks

Reply
Derek Sutton link
1/30/2021 13:54:45

Keep me in the loop on LGV trigger upgrades. All I've done so far is (supposedly) lightened up the 2nd stage of the OEM trigger [aft most screw is out as far as possible]. Still not as good as an HW Rekord - a bit "mushy." Norfolk, VA (Wish I still lived on the Cape)

Reply
Hector Medina
1/31/2021 16:35:37

Derek
Get in contact with Eric Pianori.

He makes the only American made trigger for the LGV/LGU
And it works well:

https://www.ctcustomairguns.com/hectors-airgun-blog/new-super-custom-trigger-for-the-walther-lgulgv

Keep well and shoot straight!




HM

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Hector Medina

    2012 US National WFTF Spring Piston Champion
    2012 WFTF Spring Piston Grand Prix Winner
    2013 World's WFTF Spring Piston 7th place
    2014 Texas State WFTF Piston Champion
    2014 World's WFTF Spring Piston 5th place.
    2015 Maine State Champion WFTF Piston
    2015 Massachusetts State Champion WFTF Piston
    2015 New York State Champion WFTF Piston
    2015 US National WFTF Piston 2nd Place
    2016 Canadian WFTF Piston Champion
    2016 Pyramyd Air Cup WFTF Piston 1st Place
    2017 US Nationals Open Piston 3rd Place
    2018 WFTC's Member of Team USA Champion Springers
    2018 WFTC's 4th place Veteran Springer
    2020 Puerto Rico GP Piston First Place
    2020 NC State Championships 1st Place Piston
    2022 Maryland State Champion WFTF 
    2022 WFTC's Italy Member of TEAM USA 2nd place Springers
    2022 WFTC's Italy
    2nd Place Veteran Springers

    Archives

    August 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

    Categories

    All
    Events
    Gear
    Hunting
    Tests

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly